Sadie Woods leads a structured life, and she likes it that way. As owner of her family's antique store in the town where she grew up, she is surrounded by history. The past is full of intrigue and rich memories, while the present has bills piling up, her aunt battling breast cancer, and a future full of unknowns that have her grasping for hope.

Former professional football star James Larsen just wants a quiet life for himself and his teenage daughter, Maddie. Being Deputy Sheriff in the town he calls home is just right. In the wake of his wife's death, he's able to heal without too much attention, and life has become a comfortable routine he appreciates.

When Sadie's shop is supposedly broken into, and James is the police officer called to the scene, the faded memories of attending high school together stir a connection neither of them is prepared for. While Sadie is knee-deep in trying to save her store, James is hesitant to let another woman into his and his daughter's lives.

Both hesitant to trust, Sadie and James must brave a path that includes believing there is a love worth waiting for.