Emboldened by the last remaining days of high school, Hailey writes a love letter to her neighbor. But when she runs into him at school draped around his then girlfriend, she chickens out and never tells him how she feels. Fast forward ten years, she returns home to celebrate her father's fiftieth birthday. She meets him again in town and the old feelings resurface as she finds out he's single. Will she finally give him the letter she wrote all those years ago or will fear win once again?