Annie didn't think she could find love until a handsome Englisch teacher comes into her Amish community. He is kind, strong, caring, impossibly handsome, and his deepest desire is for a wife and family to love. But then tragedy struck. He suffers a terrible injury and begins to push both God and her away. Annie begins to wonder if they are even meant to be together. Will her prayers and efforts be enough to pull her love out of the despair he is in?